Queen’s community members have been invited to provide feedback and recommendations on the reappointment of Matthew Evans as Provost. While we don’t know how this feedback will be used to inform decision making, we strongly encourage folks to fill out the form. Queen’s members also have the opportunity to serve on the Principal’s Advisory Committee (PAC), which will assess and evaluate the Provost’s performance since his appointment on August 1, 2023. Expressions of interest should be submitted by November 30 via email to principal@queensu.ca.

The invitation to participate in the appraisal process came after Senators learned, in September, that there is no formal process for reappointing a Provost nor stipulations for who should serve on the PAC (Provost Evans will be the first Provost to seek reappointment since the position was inaugurated in 2011). The Principal has not disclosed how many faculty, students, or staff will be included. But he has said that the process will follow, in a general sense, the Senate’s new Decanal Renewal and Appointments procedure (approved in March 2026), which is supposed to have an improved balance of faculty, student, staff and administrative voices in comparison with previous Queen’s practices that have stacked such committees with upper-level administrators.

Appropriate faculty representation on administrator searches was a major issue during recent QUFA negotiations, but QUFA’s proposal, which included mandatory faculty input on decanal and other senior administrator appointment processes, died at the bargaining table. In comparison with other institutions, where faculty representation is often at least 50%, Queen’s administrators largely hire and renew other administrators. Clarity about the composition of the PAC committee, and how decisions about applications to serve on it will be made, would indicate a commitment to transparency and be welcomed by the Queen’s community.

Transparency was also the order of the day at a well-attended Financial Information Forum on October 15. With Queen’s sitting on a $160 million surplus, people showed up hoping to gain clarity around the continued emphasis on squeezing (if not freezing) segments of the university. Unfortunately, the forum offered more of an illusion of candour than meaningful insight into the rationale behind Queen’s’ financial decisions. Questions submitted by members of the community were screened before being posted for upvoting, but not all questions were included, leaving attendees perplexed by the nature of the selection process. At one point, so few questions were posted that one with just six upvotes was chosen for a response. Without opportunity for follow up, the Provost could cherry pick which part of a question to answer, often responding with dismissive and defensive remarks. Such an approach does little to foster constructive dialogue. Should effective communication and the ability to engage openly with the university community not be essential qualities of a Provost?

One of the more revealing moments came at the end of the presentation segment, when the announcement was made, in reassuring tones, that Queen’s continues to maintain its high credit rating – with the VP Finance thanking faculty and staff for their hard work in maintaining this rating (as if positive ratings were the goal of the sacrifices we have been making). Chasing top-tier credit scores distorts institutional priorities away from educational quality, a direction that is felt daily by teachers and researchers on the ground. A high credit rating means a university can borrow funds at a lower rate to fund investments in built capital or other long-term priorities that serve the academic mission, but to pursue (and report on) high ratings as a good unto themselves is the tail wagging the dog.

In other austerity-related news, the Queen’s Journal continues to cover concerns about declining educational quality, in this case focusing on Queen’s poor student-faculty ratio relative to other Canadian universities: https://www.queensjournal.ca/student-to-faculty-ratio-rises-to-35-1/ . On a number of recent occasions, including at the Information Forum and at Senate, the Provost has made it clear that there will be no large scale renewal to address this problem. He has also taken to claiming that there has never been a “hiring freeze,” even though the hiring freeze was widely publicized when implemented, and, in the 2026-27 Budget Report, the “continuation of the hiring freeze” is listed first among the steps to “reduce costs and improve resource efficiency.” Semantics aside, only a tiny number of faculty hires have been made since 2024.

A recent admin-authored analysis of Queen’s’ ranking in the student-faculty ratio category, produced as part of the Bicentennial Vision, describes the situation starkly. Here, Queen’s admits it would have to hire 100 new faculty members just to move up one place among the U15 where we rank 13th (out of 15). In the absence of any stated commitment to addressing the problem, the post leaves readers with the impression that the situation is so dire it is beyond repair. Queen’s, it seems, has simply given up.

Speaking of repairs, it is hard to ignore the impact of austerity on the deteriorating physical environment at Queen’s. If you have concerns about the state of the campus environment or the future direction of planning and development at the university–including the decision to pursue a public-private partnership to finance, build and manage a new student residence on West Campus–we encourage you to attend the public information session on the Queen’s Campus Master Plan. The session will take place on November 19, from 2:00-6:00 pm in Mitchell Hall, and will offer opportunities for feedback.

In happier news, QCAA is relieved to report that, in the face of pressure from faculty members across the university, the Provost has walked back his plan to create a College of Computing and a new governance entity with it. Instead, the Queen’s Journal reports that the plan is to create new interdisciplinary courses and programs that intersect with AI “for the benefit of students at Queen’s.”

In further good news, QCAA is turning 3 years old! Keep your eyes peeled for information about a celebration, complete with cake, games, and our very own austerity awards ceremony!

Leave a Reply